Court Rejects Atiku’s Bid to Introduce Fresh Evidence in Suit Challenging Tinubu’s 2027 Eligibility

Court Rejects Atiku’s Bid to Introduce Fresh Evidence in Suit Challenging Tinubu’s 2027 Eligibility

The Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed an application by former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and the African Democratic Congress (ADC) seeking permission to introduce additional evidence in their legal challenge against President Bola Tinubu’s eligibility to contest the 2027 presidential election.

Justice Inyang Eden Ekwo, who delivered the ruling on Friday, held that the application violated the constitutional time limit for presenting evidence in pre-election disputes.

The plaintiffs had sought to amend their originating summons in a suit alleging that a forged National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) discharge certificate was submitted to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) on behalf of Tinubu.

However, the judge agreed with arguments presented by Tinubu and the other defendants that permitting the proposed amendments would introduce fresh evidence outside the constitutionally prescribed 14-day period under Section 285(9) of the 1999 Constitution.

Justice Ekwo further faulted Atiku’s claim that the proposed changes would not introduce new issues, stating that an examination of the application revealed an attempt to replace existing evidence with additional exhibits.

He maintained that allowing such a move would fundamentally alter the original case and unfairly disadvantage the defendants.

Describing the matter as time-sensitive, the judge emphasised that parties in pre-election disputes must comply strictly with the constitutional deadline.

“This is a time-bound suit and the law makes it mandatory for all exhibits to be filed in court within 14 days of occurrence of the event being challenged. Anything outside the prescribed 14 days is null and void and of no effect,” he ruled.

Justice Ekwo subsequently rejected the application, declaring:

“I find no merit in this application to bring fresh exhibit, it is hereby refused for being against the express provision of the law.

“I hereby make an order dismissing this application and is hereby dismissed.”

Despite dismissing the application, the court, following an agreement among lawyers representing the parties, scheduled December 2 for the hearing of the substantive suit.

Atiku and the ADC had instituted the case against Tinubu, the All Progressives Congress (APC) and INEC, seeking to prevent the president and his party from participating in the 2027 presidential election over allegations surrounding his NYSC discharge certificate.

In the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1888/2026, the plaintiffs alleged that the APC submitted a forged NYSC certificate belonging to Tinubu to INEC.

They consequently asked the court to compel the electoral commission to remove Tinubu’s name and that of the APC from the list of candidates and political parties for the forthcoming presidential election.

Tinubu and the APC, however, opposed the suit through a joint counter-affidavit filed on September 9, urging the court to dismiss the case for lacking merit and competence.

The defendants denied submitting any forged certificate to INEC for either the 2023 or 2027 elections. They also argued that the plaintiffs lacked the legal standing to institute the action.

Through the APC’s Director of Legal Services, Sanusi Samaila, the defendants maintained that they had not submitted Form CF001 to INEC for either election, contrary to the plaintiffs’ allegations.

They further stated that the NYSC had never disowned the discharge certificate issued to Tinubu after completing his service year.

The defendants also argued that proving a certificate was forged required a formal disclaimer from the institution purported to have issued it, citing a previous Supreme Court decision in support of their position.

INEC also challenged the competence of the suit through a preliminary objection filed on September 7 by its counsel, Dr Alex Izinyon, SAN.

The electoral commission argued that the case was statute-barred, that the plaintiffs lacked locus standi and that the originating summons disclosed no reasonable cause of action. It further accused them of abusing court processes.

INEC also faulted the plaintiffs for allegedly failing to comply with the written deposition requirements under Paragraph 7(1) of the Federal High Court Pre-Election Practice Directions (Amendment) 2026.

The commission consequently urged the court to dismiss the case, while also challenging the validity of two of the reliefs sought by the plaintiffs.

Atiku and the ADC subsequently filed their application to amend the suit on September 10, seeking the court’s permission to introduce substantial changes to their case. The application was the subject of Friday’s ruling.

CATEGORIES
Share This

COMMENTS

Wordpress (0)
Disqus ( )